Bayern Munich and Borussia Dortmund Reject Cristiano Ronaldo Signing

In a revealing account from Christian Falk’s book Transfer Insider, published by BILD, it has been disclosed that Cristiano Ronaldo’s former agent, Jorge Mendes, actively pitched the football superstar to Bayern Munich and Borussia Dortmund before his move to Al Nassr in January 2023. Despite Mendes’ efforts to highlight Ronaldo’s potential impact, both German clubs declined to pursue the transfer, citing concerns over team dynamics and financial implications.

Mendes, known as a “super agent” in football circles, prepared a detailed portfolio emphasizing Ronaldo’s on-field prowess and off-field benefits. The dossier showcased Ronaldo’s global influence, media appeal, and commercial potential, presenting him as a transformative signing capable of boosting a club’s brand and revenue streams. At the time, Ronaldo, a five-time Ballon d’Or winner, was seeking a new club after parting ways with Manchester United in late 2022, following a tumultuous second stint.

However, Bayern Munich, one of Europe’s elite clubs, expressed reservations about integrating Ronaldo into their squad. The Bavarian giants feared that his larger-than-life persona could disrupt the dressing room’s harmony. Concerns were raised about potential imbalances in the team’s wage structure, as Ronaldo’s astronomical salary demands—later reported at €200 million per year at Al Nassr—could create tension among players. Bayern’s management prioritized maintaining squad cohesion and long-term stability over the allure of a global superstar, according to Falk’s account.

Similarly, Borussia Dortmund, known for their prudent financial approach and focus on youth development, deemed the risks of signing Ronaldo too significant. While Mendes emphasized the commercial windfall Ronaldo could bring, Dortmund’s leadership concluded that these benefits did not outweigh the potential sporting and financial drawbacks. The club, which thrives on a collective team ethos, was wary of introducing a high-profile figure whose presence might overshadow their carefully cultivated squad dynamics.

With no concrete offers from European clubs, Ronaldo ultimately signed with Saudi Pro League side Al Nassr in January 2023. His record-breaking contract, valued at €200 million annually, includes both salary and lucrative endorsement deals, marking a new chapter in his career. The move came after a period of uncertainty for the Portuguese icon, whose departure from Manchester United was marred by public disputes and limited playing time under manager Erik ten Hag.

The decisions by Bayern and Dortmund reflect a broader trend among top European clubs to prioritize team unity and financial sustainability over marquee signings, even for a player of Ronaldo’s stature. As Ronaldo continues to shine in Saudi Arabia, scoring prolifically and elevating the league’s global profile, the choices made by Bayern and Dortmund highlight the delicate balance clubs must strike between star power and long-term strategy.